The Moral Impact Of The COVID-19 Pandemic On Nurses’ Burnout, Work Satisfaction And Adaptive Work Performance: The Role Of Autobiographical Memories Of Potentially Morally Injurious Events And Basic Psychological Needs Part 1

Abstract: 

The COVID-19 pandemic resulted in unprecedented exposure to Potentially Morally Injurious Events (PMIEs) for nurses, in which they were both moral transgressors and moral victims, with deleterious consequences on their psycho-social health and functioning. 

The relationship between moral injury and memory has always been a topic of concern. Moral injury refers to some actions or words we make in life that harm others. This behavior not only affects ourselves but also affects others. Memory refers to our ability to remember and recall past experiences and things. So is there a link between moral injury and memory?

Research shows that moral injury can hurt our memory. This is because moral injury will hurt our hearts, making us anxious, depressed, lost, restless, etc. These negative emotions will occupy our brain space, affect our thinking and judgment, and thus affect our memory. In addition, because moral injury can cause us inner pain and anxiety, making it difficult to focus and concentrate, this can also affect our memory.

However, we should also see that the effects of moral injury on memory are temporary. Although the negative emotions caused by moral injury will affect our memory, as long as we actively face and resolve the negative emotions, our memory can gradually recover. Therefore, we should learn how to resolve negative emotions and make our hearts healthier, thereby ensuring the normal operation of our memory and brain function.

Therefore, we should not emphasize the negative impact of moral injury, but actively guide everyone to deal with moral issues. We should respect others, adhere to the moral bottom line, and contribute to the harmonious development of society. Only in a good moral environment can we reduce the occurrence of moral harm and make people's hearts healthier, which is more conducive to the improvement and development of memory. It can be seen that we need to improve memory, and Cistanche deserticola can significantly improve memory because Cistanche deserticola is a traditional Chinese medicinal material that has many unique effects, one of which is to improve memory. The efficacy of minced meat comes from its various active ingredients, including acid, polysaccharides, flavonoids, etc. These ingredients can promote brain health in various ways.

Click know 10 ways to improve memory

Our experimental design compared memories of PMIEs with memories of severe moral transgressions (SMTs), in which participants were only moral transgressors. Drawing from Self-Determination Theory and research on moral auto-biographical episodic memories, we assessed a conceptual model describing the impact of recalling a single PMIE or SMT event on nurses’ burnout, work satisfaction, and adaptive performance. Our convenience sample comprised 614 Romanian nurses, and data was analyzed with path analysis, general linear modeling, and t-tests. 

Findings showed that memories of PMIEs, compared to SMTs, were more autonomy thwarting, being associated with more controlled work motivation, less moral learning, higher burnout, less work satisfaction, and adaptive performance. Burnout, moral learning, and work satisfaction were significant mediators of the relationships between PMIE and SMT recall and, respectively, adaptive performance. 

Our results highlight the urgency for organizational practices of moral repair for nurses after the pandemic, along with interventions meant to increase their autonomy and self-determined work motivation.

Keywords: 

potentially morally injurious event (PMIE); work satisfaction; autonomy; work motivation; COVID-19 pandemic; adaptive performance; nurses; burnout; episodic memories; selfdetermination theory.

1. Introduction

1.1. Potentially Morally Injurious Events in Healthcare during the COVID-19 Pandemic

During the COVID-19 pandemic, resource scarcity led to work-related ethical challenges that affected healthcare providers’ work performance, psychological health, and functionality [1–3]. The necessity of making very difficult, often life-and-death decisions about resource prioritizing resulted in frequent exposure to PMIEs [2–5]. 

PMIEs are severe moral transgressions for which the individual feels responsible, either because they perpetrated them or because they stood by passively and failed to act according to their moral principles [2]. PMIEs are associated with experiencing victimization and sometimes trauma, due to the perceived inability to act differently under circumstantial constraints [1–5]. 

Moral injury is the result of exposure to PMIEs, although not all exposure to PMIEs results in moral injury, it also has other detrimental consequences on psycho-social health and functioning [2].

1.2. Autobiographical Episodic Memories of Moral Transgressions

Autobiographical episodic memories of moral transgressions represent vivid, emotional, and detailed encodings of moral violations inflicted, witnessed, or suffered by the individual. Recent research suggests that there are differences in how vividly and readily we recall these memories according to our perceived roles of moral perpetrators or moral victims [6]. 

Also, the more severe the moral transgression, the better we recall it, especially when we perpetrated it [7]. This seems to occur even though recalling severe, self-perpetrated moral violations is accompanied by more intense negative affect and psychological distress than recalling more minor ones [7,8]. To the best of our knowledge, there are no studies that examine the effects of recalling memories of moral transgressions during which people perceived themselves as both victims and perpetrators [2], such as PMIEs.

1.3. Autonomy Thwarting in Work-Related, Autobiographical Episodic Memories

According to Self-Determination Theory (SDT) [9,10], workers’ motivation, thriving, and performance depend on the satisfaction/thwarting of three basic psychological needs: autonomy, the need to feel volitionally authentic in your behavior; competence, the need to feel efficient and effectual; relatedness, the need to feel connected to work colleagues [10]. 

Episodic memories of specific, non-repeated work-related events during which either of these three needs were thwarted can have a unique and significant impact on motivation, work satisfaction, and burnout, for up to two years [11,12]. The more thwarted the need(s), the more likely it is that the episodic memory becomes a self-defining memory [11]. Self-defining memories represent enduring concerns or unresolved conflicts, central and important to personal identity, which guide our behavior and shape our representations, all the while influencing occupational well-being and performance [11,13].

1.4. Work Motivation

According to the basic psychological need satisfaction experienced at work, motivation can be self-determined or controlled [9,10]. When workers’ needs are met, their motivation is self-determined: they perform their activities out of enjoyment, feeling that their job fits their values and identity and that they exercise freedom in choosing their actions [9]. When their needs are thwarted, motivation becomes controlled, and workers perform duties out of guilt, external pressure, or for rewards/to avoid punishment [9,11].

1.5. Moral Learning Following Moral Memory Recall

By and large, people consider themselves moral, and they need to feel and define themselves as such [8]. This moral identity is threatened by the frequent recall of their most severe moral violations [7]. 

However, recent studies found that remembering our more severe moral transgressions is followed by the simulation of morally upward counterfactuals— alternative moral courses of action (i.e., moral learning) [7]. 

The functional explanation of this phenomenon is that it represents how we learn from our past mistakes, especially since morally upward counterfactuals are followed by increased intentions to behave morally better in similar future situations [7]. Autonomy is a self-regulatory mechanism for moral learning: when autonomy is low, the number and self-regulatory quality of counterfactuals are reduced, leading to helplessness rather than learning and improvement [14].

1.6. Burnout

During the COVID-19 pandemic, nurses experienced more burnout than other health workers [15]. The burnout syndrome describes a loss of interest in work, a sense of hopelessness, depersonalization, and exhaustion [16]. In nurses, burnout jeopardized patient recovery more than any other factor during the COVID-19 pandemic [17]. It also contributed greatly to decreased productivity, mental, and physical health [18].

1.7. Work Satisfaction

Work satisfaction describes the degree to which people like their jobs and find them satisfying [19]. The pandemic decreased nurses’ work satisfaction [20], which led to high turnover intentions and poor quality of care, leading researchers to urge relevant stakeholders to take immediate action so that nurses feel supported organizationally in this regard [19].

1.8. Adaptive Performance

During the COVID-19 pandemic, nurses’ adaptive performance was an essential employee resource in managing day-to-day crises [21]. Adaptive performance was defined as “task-performance-directed behaviors individuals enact in response to or anticipation of changes relevant to job-related tasks” [22] (pp. 54–55). It measures the extent to which workers learn and apply new practices and strategies when confronted with (un)anticipated changes that may affect work outcomes.

1.9. Current Study

The COVID-19 pandemic inflicted an invisible epidemic of moral injury among healthcare providers, affecting nurses the most [1,2]. Moral injury was associated with secondary traumatic stress, generalized anxiety, depression, suicidal ideation, post-traumatic stress disorder, burnout, stress, and turnover intentions [23]. First, we must decrease the negative impact of potentially morally injurious events (PMIEs) on nurses’ mental health and performance [3,4].

Our main aim is to examine the long-term consequences of nurses’ exposure to PMIEs during the COVID-19 pandemic on burnout, work satisfaction, and adaptive performance. Drawing from recent research on moral autobiographical memories and self-determination theory (SDT), we constructed a theoretical model (Figure 1) to investigate how memories of PMIEs affect psycho-social and occupational parameters beyond moral injury. Using an experimental design, we evaluate three paths through which memories of PMIEs may decrease nurses’ adaptive performance, with burnout, moral learning, and work satisfaction as the main mechanisms proposed (Figure 1).

PMIEs are severe moral transgressions during which individuals perceive themselves as both moral victims and moral transgressors, which is why we chose to compare them in our experiment with memories of severe moral transgressions (SMTs) during which individuals perceive themselves as moral transgressors only. Given the importance of both types of events in (re)defining nurses’ professional identities and representations of the workplace [2,23,24], our first hypothesis was that memories of SMTs and PMIEs are self-defining memories, highly important, and central to the self (H1).

Below, we present the three paths through which memories of PMIEs during the COVID-19 pandemic (as compared to memories of SMTs) might predict lower adaptive performance in nurses (Figure 1) and refer to previous results to support our hypotheses. To avoid repetitiveness, the relationships common to all three paths (i.e., between recalling PMIEs, autonomy thwarting, and work motivation), along with the direct influence of recalling PMIEs on adaptive performance are presented only for the first path.

1. Path 1: Burnout as the Main Mechanism

Our second hypothesis was that autonomy would be more thwarted in episodic memories of PMIEs than SMTs (H2; path a in Figure 1), because SMTs are intentional acts, whereas PMIEs are perceived as coerced [2,23]. As exposure to PMIEs was associated with higher burnout [25] independently of autonomy thwarting, we expected a unique differential contribution of type of memory on burnout as well (path k in Figure 1). 

Studies so far did not investigate how exposure to PMIEs might impact adaptive performance, to our knowledge. However, PMIEs can negatively impact general work performance, both proximally and distally, in nurses and other healthcare workers [26]. Thus, we also expected a unique contribution of PMIE recall in explaining adaptive performance as compared to SMT recall (path I in Figure 1).

The differential autonomy thwarting between memories of PMIEs and SMTs should lead to higher self-determined motivation for memories of SMTs than for memories of PMIEs, which should be followed by more controlled motivation (H3, path b in Figure 1) [9,10]. Past research showed that basic psychological need satisfaction operated as a mediator between self-defining work memories and burnout [11,12]. 

Because motivation is dependent on need satisfaction/thwarting, and motivation can predict burnout [21] (path d in Figure 1), we expected to find support for the conceptual relationships described in Figure 1 by the paths a*b*d. Given all the above and the fact that lower burnout can increase adaptive performance [26,27] (path f in Figure 1), our fifth hypothesis (H5) was that the type of memory recall, autonomy thwarting, and work motivation should differentially affect adaptive performance through burnout (H5; path a*b*d*f in Figure 1).

2. Path 2: Work Satisfaction as the Main Mechanism

Because exposure to PMlEs was associated with lower work satisfaction (22) independently of autonomy thwarting, we expected a unique differential contribution of type memory on work satisfaction (path j in Figure 1). Since basic psychological need satisfaction operated as a mediator between self-defining work memories and work satisfaction (11,12and motivation predicted work satisfaction (28) (path e in Figure 1), we expected to find support for the conceptual relationship described in Figure 1 by the path a"b*e. 

Given all the above and the fact that higher work satisfaction can increase adaptive performance (26,27path h in Figure 1), our sixth hypothesis (H6) was that the type of memory recall, autonomy thwarting, and work motivation should differentially affect adaptive performance through work satisfaction (H6, path a*b*e"h in Figure 1).

For more information:1950477648nn@gmail.com