Employment Of Phenolic Compounds From Olive VegetationWater in Broiler Chickens: Effects On Gut Microbiota And On The Shelf Life Of Breast Fillets (part 1)
Mar 12, 2022
Please contact oscar.xiao@wecistanche.com for more information
Abstract: Olive vegetation water(OVW) is a by-product with a noticeable environmental impact; however, its polyphenols may be reused from food and feed manufacture as high-value ingredients with antioxidant/antimicrobial activities. The effect of dietary supplementation with OVW polyphenols on the gut microbiota, carcass and breast quality, shelf life, and lipid oxidation in broiler chickens has been studied. Chicks were fed diets supplemented with crude phenolic concentrate(CPC) obtained from OVW(220 and 440 mg/kg phenols equivalent) until reaching commercial size. Cloacal microbial community (rRNA16S sequencing)was monitored during the growth period. Breasts were submitted to culture-dependent and-independent microbiological analyses during their shelf-life. Composition, fatty acid concentration, and lipid oxidation of raw and cooked thawed breasts were measured. Growth performance and gut microbiota were only slightly affected by the dietary treatments, while animal age influenced the cloacal microbiota. The supplementation was found to reduce the shelf life of breasts due to the growth of spoilers. Chemical composition and lipid oxidation were not affected. The hydroxytyrosol (HT)concentration varied from 178.6 to 292.4 ug/kg in breast muscle at the beginning of the shelf-life period. The identification of HT in meat demonstrates that the absorption and metabolism of these compounds were occurring efficiently in the chickens.
Keywords: olive vegetation water; phenolic compounds; broilers; gut microbiota; breast shelf life

Please click here to know more
1. Introduction
Aviculture is an efficient and sustainable animal production system. Intensive selection plans over the last fifty years have allowed us to obtain chickens that convert feed into muscle mass with a high level of efficiency[1]. However, at the same time, the growth of the poultry industry and the spread of intensive breeding systems have led to broiler chickens being exposed to several stressors. Stressors may lead to the production of reactive oxygen species(ROS) that may injure cellular components such as lipids, proteins, and DNA, having negative consequences for growth performance and the immune response. Animals have greater exposure to disease, and an increase in lipid peroxidation reduces the meat quality [2]. The addition of antioxidants, such as phenolics, to the diets of broilers to reduce the effects of stressors and stimulate an immune response, has been proposed in several studies [3-5]. Phenolic compounds are natural antioxidants and antimicrobials derived from various plant materials |6l. Evidence of their beneficial effect on human health has been demonstrated by several epidemiological studies [7,8], with the health-promoting activities of dietary being confirmed by in vitro data. These studies have demonstrated an association between the consumption of phenolic compounds-rich foods and a reduced risk of developing several diseases, including chronic diseases and cancer [9-11].
One of the peculiarities of olives and derived products is the presence of hydrophilic phenols responsible for the sensory aspects but also for biological activity. Phenolic acids and alcohols, flavonoids, lignans and secoiridoids are some of the classes of phenolic compounds present in virgin olive oil. Secoiridoids, present in the olive drupe in the glycosidic form, are interesting for their bioactivity.

Cistanche can improve immunity
Some compounds, such as oleuropein, demethyloleuropein, and verbascoside, are present throughout the fruit although often more abundant in the pulp, while nüzhenide is contained only in the seed. Oleuropein, although its concentration decreases with ripening, and demethyloleuropein is the most concentrated phenolic compound [12].
In virgin olive oil, secoiridoids are present as final aglycon derivatives: 3,4-DHPEA-EDA from oleuropein and demethyloleuropein and, p-HPEA-EDA from ligstroside; more-over oleuropein is characterized by a bitter taste [13].
It is important to point out that the production of olive oil generates polluting by-products with antimicrobial and antioxidant activity (e.g., Olive Vegetation Water, OVW); in fact, about 90%of the phenolic compounds present in the olive is lost with the water that is released during pressing. Therefore, even if in different concentrations, in the OVW aglyconic derivatives are present similar to those of oil such as 3,4-DHPEA,p-HPEA, Verbascoside, 34-DHPE-EDA, and p-HPEA-EDA [13].
Phenolic compounds can be recovered thanks to membrane technologies and could be used in the production of food and feed.
The qualitative-quantitative composition of the phenols present in the virgin olive oil and in the OVW depends on numerous factors such as the genetic and agronomic factors and, extraction-process technology [14].
The effects of the addition of olive phenolic compounds to the poultry diet have been reported in several studies with contrasting effects on growth performance [15-19]. The different effects observed might depend on the effective bioavailability of the different molecules. Regarding the bioavailability of phenolic compounds, the gut microbiota exerts a fundamental role, as described by several authors [20-22], that might operate in a reciprocal relationship. First, the gut microbiota biotransforms dietary polyphenols into their metabolites, increasing their bioavailability. Second, through their antioxidant and antimicrobial activity, phenolics modulate the composition of the gut microbial community, mostly through the inhibition of pathogenic bacteria and the stimulation of beneficial bacteria. Therefore, the interactions of dietary phenolic compounds and the gut microbiota may impact host health.

In this study, the effects of the dietary supplementation of broiler chickens with OVW phenolic compounds on the gut microbiota composition, carcass yield and quality, and shelf life of breast meat were investigated. Moreover, the antioxidant activity of the phenol compound retained in the muscular tissue was studied on raw breast and cooked thawed breast.
2. Results and Discussion 2.1.Growth Performance
Table 1 reports the productive performance of broilers prior to slaughter. The groups did not show differences either during the first period (same diet) or after the experimental dietary treatment.The daily weight gain, daily feed intake, and feed conversion rate were similar among chickens fed the LO, L1, and L2 diets. No effects of dietary treatment on the slaughter yield or carcass quality were observed (Table 2).In the literature, little data on the use of olive vegetation waters in chicken feeding are available. Using different concentrations of OVW in the diet, reference [23] found greater live and carcasses weights of chickens fed phenolic compounds, but no dietary effects on the dressing percentage
were reported. However, it should be noted that the live weight at the slaughter of their chickens was about half that obtained in the present study. Other authors have tested the effects of extra virgin olive oil [24] or dried olive pulp inclusion [25] highlighting a positive effect of dietary integration on rearing performance. Other studies have evaluated the supplementation with olive leaves, rich in oleuropein [26], or olive leaves and olive cake [27] and have not found significant effects on rearing performance.


2.2. Phenol Concentration in the Diet and Breast Muscle
The concentrations of phenols in the diets used in this study are shown in Table S2. The actual total phenol values, 175.5 and 320.2 mg/kg for diets L1 and L2, respectively, were 20.2% and 27.2% lower than the theoretical ones indicated in paragraph 2.2. The concentration of hydroxytyrosol (HT) was 97 and 174.6 mg/kg for L1 and L2, respectively. In the breast muscle, among the phenol compounds in the diet (Table S2), only HT was found (Table 3). Its value at the beginning of the shelf-life period (24 h) was proportional to the concentration of HT in the feed. The absorption of tyrosol (T) and HT in humans is dose-dependent [28], while in poultry, it seems that no more than 10% of phenols are absorbed in the small intestine [29]. After 10 days of storage at 4 ◦C, the residual concentration of HT in breast muscle was no longer detectable in the L1 group, while it was approximately one-fourth of the initial concentration in the L2 group. In a sample of the control group, the measured HT concentration was 78 µg/kg. According to de la Torre [30], the presence of HT in the biological fluids of human volunteers, even after several hours of fasting, is the result of dopamine metabolism. Studies conducted on animal models have shown that especially in the presence of alcohol, the metabolism of dopamine produces significant quantities of HT in addition to the usual terminal product represented by 3,4-dihydroxy phenylacetic acid. Branciari et al. [31] assessed chicken diets with a total phenolic content (mainly T and HT) ranging from 14 to 24 mg/kg (approximately 12 times lower than those used in the present study). The authors identified T, rather than HT, in samples of breast muscle, in concentrations ranging from 8 to 47 ug/kg. This was 5 to 33 times lower than the concentrations measured in the breast samples of the L2 group of the present study. They found only sulphate metabolites of HT in minor concentrations in the muscular tissue.

2.3. Gut Microbiota Profiles
The gut microbiota composition was determined from cloacal swabs collected from broilers during the breeding period at 23,34, and 44 days of age. The DNA was extracted and used as a template for rRNA16S amplicon library preparation. Libraries were sequenced using lumina technology (Illumina, San Diego, CA, USA). The composition of the gut bacterial community was analyzed in order to evaluate the effects of OVW polyphenol dietary supplementation. The multivariate analysis demonstrated a significant effect of the age of animals on the gut bacterial community composition (p<0.001, R2=0.261). On the contrary, the diets enriched with CPC seemed not to affect the gut microbiota. The substantial alterations of the microbiota related to the age of the animals have been widely reported in the literature [30-33]. At 23 days of age, the microbial community was dominated by Proteobacteria (mostly by members of the Enterobacteriaceae family); however, the concentration of these species reduced during the growth of the animals with concomitant increases in the Firmicutes and Bacteroidetes phyla (see Figure 1A, B). The Lactobacillaceae family and the Ruminococcaceae and Lachnospiraceae families (both belonging to the Clostridia class)increased in concentration at34 and 44 days of age, respectively (Figure 1B). The biodiversity (reported as the Shannon alpha-diversity index) increased from 23 to 34-44 days of age(Figure 1C). The expected modification of the microbiota composition linked to the administration of different diets was difficult to identify due to the wide intra-individual variability (related to the shorter gut tract and faster intestinal transit in poultry than in other food animals) and the consistent changes related to age [3435.
2.4.Sensory Shelf Life, pH, and Drip Loss
Figure 2A reports the SI evolution during storage. Breasts maintained their freshness scores until 200 h of refrigeration. After this period, rapid sensory decay was observed. Samples from diets L1 and L2 had sensory shelf lives of 256-263h, while most breasts from animals that consumed the control diet did not overcome the demerit threshold (SI=1.8)of 264 h. Samples with SI lower than 1.8 were considered spoiled.
Statistical analyses revealed that supplementation with CPC only affected the sensory index at 156 and 256 h (p<0.05). SI suggested that the shelf-life behavior of samples differed, especially in the latest phase of conservation.
Dietary treatment did not affect the pH(p >0.05; Figure 2C) which, instead, was affected by the storage time (p<0.001; Figures S1 and S2 in Supplementary Materials). For the drip loss(Figure 2B), in addition to time (p<0.001; Figure S3), the effect of dietary treatment was also statistically significant (p<0.001)with L1 having the lowest value (Figure S4). Branciariet al. [31] reported that the pH after 24 h and drip loss of chicken meat was not affected by the diet integration with polyphenols derived from the semi-solid destoned olive cake. Changes in the pH and drip loss during the storage period are common findings and are also affected by the type of packaging [36].


2.5. Shelf-Life of Breast Fillets Determined with Culture-Dependent and Culture-Independent Methods
The effect of CPC supplementation seemed to affect some microbial targets (TVC; Pseudomonas, Shewanella, and Enterobacteriaceae)but only after 216 h of conservation (Table S3)Confirming the culture-dependent results, a comparison of the microbial community pro-files assessed by rRNA16S amplicon sequencing demonstrated a strong effect of time (p<0.001). During the shelf-life period, the biodiversity gradually reduced and the composition of the community was clearly modified (see Figure S5A,B), with an increase in the relative abundance of Proteobacteria and decreases in Firmicutes and Bacteroidetes(Figure S5C). At 11 days(264 h of conservation), as for the cultural methods (see below), differentiation of the community depending on the presence of CPC was evident. The Principal Coordinate Analysis (PCoA), presented in Figure 3B, demonstrated this effect, and this was confirmed by the Adonis multivariate analysis(T11p<0.001). In terms of the composition of the community, the culture-independent analysis (resumed in the heat map presented in Figure 3A)confirmed the presence of meat spoilers such as Pseudomonas, Acinetobacter, and Shewanella, that progressively increased their presence in the community during the shelf-life period, while the concentration of bacteria from fecal contamination (Fecalibacterium, Coprococcus, and Escherichia) reduced.

In general, L1 and L2 diets were associated with higher levels of Pseudomonas spp., a specific group of spoilage organisms that are mainly involved in the sensory decay of poultry meat [37].
These results agree with previously reported data on normal breasts under refrigera-tion[38] with a slightly lower microbial load in the latest part of the shelf-life period. Few works have reported the effects of phenols resulting from waste products of the olive oil industry in the broiler diet [29]. Therefore, the effects of olive mill wastewater extract on the microbial quality and shelf life of chicken breasts have rarely been investigated. The reported results suggest a small effect of the phenols retained inside the breast meat, with an increase in microbial growth of spoiler targets during the last period of conservation. As previously reported in in vitro studies, similar extracts show antimicrobial activities, especially in gram-positive bacteria [39]. Moreover, supplementation with olive mill wastewater concentrate seems to reduce the incidence of foodborne pathogens, such as Campylobacter spp., in the feces of broilers [23]. Here, the retained phenols inside the breast could modify the microbial environment, favoring the presence of Shewanella and Pseudomonas. However, mild impacts on sensory data during the shelf-life period were observed.
The growth parameters of TVC and Pseudomonas are reported in Table 4. The microbial growth was very similar among diets with an initial Lag phase for TVC during the first 5-7 days of refrigeration. Due to their psychrotrophic habits, Pseudomonas spp. showed a very limited adaptation period (Lag time 0-4 days). Microbial growth, as shown by the plateauing of parameters, overcame the specific spoilage thresholds suggested for chicken breast samples stored in the air [37]. Growth parameters allowed the estimation of microbial shelf life, which ended earlier than sensory decay in all observed cases, When the microbial load exceeded 7 log10 CFU/g, particularly for Pseudomonas spp., many spoilage mechanisms, including amino acid degradation, slime, and off-odor formation, increased, and there was a faster decrease of sensory attributes. As observed for the SI, the estimated microbial shelf life was longer in the sample that consumed the control diet. Considering Pseudomonas as a specific spoilage marker, it is possible to assume a 9.5-day shelf life for L1 and L2 breasts as compared with 11 days for the control samples(Table 4).

2.6. Proximate Composition, Cooking Loss, and Fatty Acid Composition
The composition analysis did not show differences between the samples of the control group and those with diet added of CPC(Table 5). The cooking treatment caused significant increases in protein and fat, which were dependent on the overall increase in the dry matter following the loss of water during cooking. For the dry matter values, only a significant difference in the ash concentration was shown. No differences were observed with respect to cooking loss. Branciari et al.31] did not find any differences in the proximate composition of thawed breasts from Ross 308 broilers fed diets supplemented with a semi-solid olive cake at 82.5 g/Kg and 165.0 g/Kg of diet. Giannini et al. [40] feeding Ross 308 up to 42 days with experimental diets supplemented with oregano blend(300 g/ton)plus attapulgite(3 kg/ton) and with a mix of oregano and laurel (500 g/ton) did not find differences on proximate composition either on breast nor on thigh meat. Starcevic et al. [41]supplementing the feeds for chicken Ross 308 with thymol (200 mg/kg), tannic acid (5g/kg), and gallic acid(5g/kg) up to 35 days found higher fat content and lower protein content in breast meat of the tannic acid group compared to control one. At the same time, the feed intake of the experimental groups was higher than the control group, suggesting that the resulting extra energy produced could have been deposited as fat in the muscular tissue. The addition of fermented or enzymatically fermented dried olive pomace to broiler chickens' diet (Ross 308)at three inclusion levels (7.5,15 and 30%)significantly increased protein content and decreased fat in breast muscle of the experimental groups [42]. Table 6 presents the fatty acid profiles of the breast muscle. No significant variation was shown among experimental groups, except for significantly higher percentages of the two essential fatty acids(C18:2 n6 and C18:3 n3) in chickens that consumed the L2 diet.
Although without statistical significance, the concentration of long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids showed an opposite trend, with values tending to be higher in the control group. The relative abundance of essential fatty acids(18:2 n6 and 18:3 n3) and their long-chain polyunsaturated derivatives (20:4 n6, 20:5 n3,22:5 n3,22:6 n3)depends also on the activity of tissue enzymes with desaturase function. Therefore, the regulation of enzymatic activity can cause a consistent variation in the concentration of these fatty acids in the liver and other peripheral tissues. The phenols, and among these hydroxytyrosol, can under certain conditions affect the lipid metabolism also through the regulation of desaturase activity. Valenzuela et al. [43] observed that dietary supplementation with 5 mg/day of hydroxytyrosol in mice did not cause changes in either the blood or tissue lipid profile. Administration of a high-calorie diet causes an immediate decrease in the hepatic concentration of total n6-LCPUFA and total n3-LCPUFA in mice. This effect is rebalanced when the high-calorie diet is added with 5 mg of hydroxytyrosol. HT, therefore, seems to have a normalizing effect on the desaturase activity (mainly △-5 and A-6 desaturase) in conditions of food stress. On the contrary, sesamin (a phenol ascribed to the lignans group) has shown an inhibiting action on rat liver △-5 desaturase [44]. Therefore, in the experimental conditions of the present study is the absence of both food and environmental stress factors, the integration of the diet with an extract rich in polyphenols does not seem to determine significant changes in the enzymatic desaturase activity and consequently, the lipid profile of the breast muscle tissue was unaffected.
This article is extracted from Molecules 2021, 26, 4307. https://doi.org/10.3390/molecules26144307






