Taxonomic Revision Of Cistanche Deserticola Ma And Cistanche Salsa(C. A. Mey.) Beck Based On Specimen, Morphological, And Molecular Characteristics
Jan 20, 2026
3 Discussion
3.1 Philological and Literature-Based Evidence
From the Eastern Han Dynasty's Divine Farmer's Classic of Materia Medica to materia medica works of the Qing Dynasty, historical records of Cistanche display a clear trajectory of evolution. Texts from the Eastern Han period already recognized its principal effects, including tonifying the five viscera, strengthening yang and enriching essence, and regulating reproductive functions in both men and women. The place of origin was vaguely described as "mountain valleys," without distinction of specific biological sources. From the Wei–Jin–Southern and Northern Dynasties through the Tang and Five Dynasties, works such as Wu Pu's Materia Medica, Collected Annotations on the Materia Medica, Rihuazi's Materia Medica, and Shu Materia Medica recorded, for the first time, the saline-type Cistanche and gradually began to differentiate between types: the desert-type from Longxi and the Western Qiang region was described as flattened in shape, soft and moist, with many flowers and a sweet taste; the saline-type from the northern regions and along Hedong had shorter roots, fewer flowers, and slightly inferior efficacy.

During the Song, Ming, and Qing dynasties, texts such as Kaibao Materia Medica, Illustrated Materia Medica, Extended Meanings of the Materia Medica, Ben Cao Cheng Ya Ban Ji, New Compilation of the Materia Medica, and Ben Cao Shu Gou Yuan provided systematic records of origin, morphology, harvesting and processing methods, and detailed identification of adulterants (e.g., herbaceous Congrong and "Jinlian" roots used as substitutes), forming a relatively complete geoherbal identification system. The literature indicates that the saline Cistanche (C. salsa) appears earlier in medical texts than C. deserticola, and that over a long course of medicinal practice, the two underwent a transition from being conflated and used interchangeably to being gradually distinguished as "Rou Cong Rong" (C. deserticola) and "saline Cistanche" (C. salsa).

Overall, records across successive dynasties not only provide continuous documentation on morphology, flavor, efficacy, and origins, but also offer solid historical foundations for modern classification and identification based on morphology and molecular systematics, thereby supporting the conclusion that C. deserticola and C. salsa constitute a closely related species complex.
According to the Flora of China's morphological descriptions of C. deserticola and C. salsa, and through comparisons with living material, herbarium specimens, and historical literature-combined with floral traits of C. salsa reported from different countries (Tables 3–4)-we infer: (i) Diagnostic characters for distinguishing the two are ambiguous and lack specificity. For example, the length of bracts in the inflorescence, calyx-lobe morphology, and corolla coloration show continuous variation. This aligns with findings by Liu Guojun and Zhang Zhiyun, indicating that current morphological criteria are insufficient to effectively separate the two, and that stable diagnostic traits with taxonomic value need to be established or corroborated with molecular systematics. (ii) The two species show extensive overlap in morphology and host range. Floral traits vary widely, and host types are diverse. Previous studies have indicated that host species, soil salinity, and moisture conditions can significantly influence the morphology and chemical composition of parasitic plants. In C. deserticola, plant size, floral morphology, and coloration vary with the host: when parasitic on Haloxylon, plants are tall with thick stems; flowers often show yellow/white with purple lobes and robust spikes; when parasitic on Atriplex canescens (or related chenopods), plants are relatively slender, with pink-purple flowers bearing white/yellow mottling and more compact spikes. In C. salsa, parasitism on Nitraria results in shorter plants with thinner stems and pale-purple flowers paired with yellow/white; bracts are shorter. When parasitic on Kalidium gracile (Hetiutao/Hehead grass), plants are even shorter, with mostly white to pale-yellow flowers and sparse spikes. If parasitic on Haloxylon, the flowers show purple-white mottling, and plant size is intermediate between C. salsa on Nitraria and C. deserticola on Haloxylon (Figures 7–8). Given that growth, physiology, and morphology of parasitic plants are strongly influenced by their hosts, Orobanchaceae species often exhibit notable intraspecific variation in form and color; host specificity may facilitate the formation of small forms or varieties with morphological and physiological differences. Molecular systematics and ecological studies have likewise shown that C. salsa and C. deserticola are genetically close; their morphological differences may stem more from ecological adaptation and host-induced phenotypic variation rather than strict species-level divergence.
3.2 Morphological Study
Comparative morphological analyses reveal a high degree of similarity in overall architectural traits, such as leaves being ovate to oblong-ovate, calyces being campanulate with shallow 5-lobing, corollas being tubular-campanulate, and fruits being ovoid. Nonetheless, subtle yet stable differences do exist, such as plant height and floral structures: C. deserticola plants are generally taller, with linear-lanceolate bracts usually longer than the corolla; C. salsa plants are shorter, with ovate-lanceolate bracts. These differences may relate to their respective pollination ecologies and resource allocation strategies. Longer bracts in C. deserticola may function as more conspicuous visual signals to attract specific pollinators. In C. deserticola, both the filament base and anthers are covered with wrinkled long villous hairs, and a nectary is present at the base of the ovary; in C. salsa, hairs occur on the anthers and filament base, but the ovary is glabrous. Although these microstructural differences are not easily observed in the field, they may play key roles in preventing selfing, selecting pollinators, or resisting pathogens, serving as potential bases for reproductive isolation. Flower color in C. deserticola (pale yellow to pale purple) shows a certain range of variation, whereas flower color in C. salsa (white tube with pale-purple lobes) is relatively stable. Floral coloration is a critical signal in plant–pollinator interactions, and this difference may suggest that the two have experienced different pollinator selection pressures during adaptation to distinct habitats.

Differences in plant height, bract length, and related traits may be associated with optimizing reproductive success under their respective habitat conditions. For instance, in open desert environments, taller inflorescences and more conspicuous bracts may facilitate wind-mediated pollen dispersal or attract pollinators from greater distances; in saline–alkali grasslands, shorter inflorescences may help reduce water loss from transpiration and mitigate wind damage.
Cross-sectional structural differences not only provide visual morphological criteria for identification but also offer important references for taxonomic research. Differences in vascular arrangement, cambial rings, and pith development may be closely related to growth habits, host types, and ecological conditions. The highly similar radial vascular structures of C. deserticola and C. salsa, together with their multi-host strategy and molecular systematics, support the view that they form a closely related species complex. In contrast, the star-dotted vascular bundle structure in C. tubulosa aligns with its specific hosts and ecological distribution, reflecting stronger ecological specialization.
3.3 Molecular Systematics Based on Three Genomic Marker Sets
Three independent genetic systems (plastid, mitochondrial, and nuclear genes) all support, with high confidence, that the two species form sister lineages. Such cross-genome concordance strongly suggests that they share a recent, distinct common ancestor and may have undergone a rapid speciation event, or that gene flow still exists within their zones of sympatry. This finding challenges traditional morphology-based taxonomy, as the two have largely been distinguished by habitat (typical desert vs. saline–alkali land) and minor floral differences. The study recommends that, in future research on medicinal resource identification, conservation biology, and species delimitation, these two be considered as a tightly knit "closely related species complex."
On the other hand, plastid genomes reveal deeper internal diversity within Cistanche. The five Cistanche species analyzed are divided into four clades, which is far from a simple pattern of intrageneric differentiation within a single monophyletic group. C. sinensis emerges as an early diverging, independent clade (Clade I), and its distinct phylogenetic position is supported by molecular evidence-consistent with distinguishing features such as corolla color and bract morphology. Similarly, the clear separation of the non-native C. phelypaea (Clade IV) suggests that multiple independent adaptive radiations may have occurred across Eurasia within Cistanche. C. tubulosa clusters with the C. deserticola–C. salsa lineage with moderate support. Such moderate support is a typical signal of "rapid radiation" in phylogenetics, wherein several lineages diverged from a common ancestor within a short timeframe, resulting in insufficient shared derived characters for robust resolution.
Comparing plastid and mitochondrial genomes in resolving relationships within Cistanche reveals both concordance and potential conflict. Both strongly support the sister relationship between C. deserticola and C. salsa, but both provide only moderate support for the placement of C. tubulosa. This inconsistency may reflect the true evolutionary history, namely incomplete lineage sorting; different genomes, due to differing evolutionary rates and inheritance mechanisms, may record divergent histories. In plants, mitochondrial genomes are typically maternally inherited with low recombination, while plastid genomes are also usually maternally inherited. Therefore, the "species tree" they reveal may primarily reflect the history of the maternal lineage. Incorporation of nuclear gene data provides a biparental perspective, and its concordance with organellar genomes greatly strengthens confidence in inferences about the true evolutionary history. In this study, the mitochondrial protein-based phylogenetic tree successfully recovered six major families within Lamiales, including Orobanchaceae, in general agreement with large-scale plastid-based phylogenies. These results provide a robust phylogenetic framework for in-depth exploration of the molecular mechanisms underlying the evolution of parasitism in Orobanchaceae.

Taken together, analyses of plastid, mitochondrial, and nuclear datasets indicate that C. deserticola and C. salsa are genetically closer to each other than to other congeneric species, supporting the view that they constitute a closely related species complex. This finding is consistent with earlier chloroplast-fragment-based work (rps2, rpl16–rpl14) and whole-genome studies, further corroborating their systematic position. Their close kinship also explains the substantial overlap in morphology and host range, suggesting that some morphological differences likely arise more from ecological adaptation and host-induced phenotypic variation than from strict species-level divergence.
These phylogenetic results have important implications for taxonomy, resource conservation, and the medicinal materials industry. On one hand, they provide a molecular foundation for establishing a scientifically reliable species identification system, helping to resolve the conflation of C. deserticola and C. salsa; on the other, they facilitate precise traceability and germplasm management, providing a theoretical basis for the standardized production and sustainable use of traditional Chinese medicinal materials. Clarifying intergeneric and intrageneric relationships also offers a reference for further studies on the evolutionary history of parasitic plants in Orobanchaceae, host adaptation mechanisms, and ecological strategies.
Integrating specimen verification, morphological comparisons, and tripartite molecular systematic evidence from plastid, mitochondrial, and nuclear genomes, this study concludes that C. deserticola and C. salsa form a "closely related species complex" with high morphological and genetic homogeneity. The results provide scientific evidence for rectifying the origin of Cistanche, supporting rational clinical application. This has practical significance for protecting and expanding new germplasm resources of Cistanche, achieving sustainable utilization, and improving quality standards.
References
[1] Wang W C. Flora of China: Volume 69 [M]. Beijing: Science Press, 1990: 254.
[2] A concise and readable annotations of Shen Nong's classic of materia medica [M]. Sun X Y, compiled. Xu B, annotated. Beijing: China Press of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 1976: 455.
[3] Tao H J. Compendium of materia medica with annotations [M]. Wang J K, edited and collated. Nanjing: Jiangsu Phoenix Publishing House, 2023: 726.
[4] Li S Z. Compendium of materia medica [M]. Beijing: People's Medical Publishing House, 1975: 880.
[5] Wu P. Wu Pu's materia medica [M]. Beijing: People's Medical Publishing House, 1987: 68.
[6] National Pharmacopoeia Committee. Chinese pharmacopoeia: Volume I [M]. Beijing: China Medical Science Press, 2025: 144.
[7] Lei L, Song Z H, Tu P F. Advances in research of chemical constituents in plants of Cistanche Hoffing. et Link [J]. Chin Tradit Herb Drugs, 2003, 34(5): 473-476.
[8] Xiong Q, Kadota S, Tani T, et al. Antioxidative effects of phenylethanoids from Cistanche deserticola [J]. Biol Pharm Bull, 1996, 19(12): 1580-1585.
[9] Gu L, Xiong W T, Zhuang Y L, et al. Effects of Cistanche deserticola extract on penis erectile response in castrated rats [J]. Pak J Pharm Sci, 2016, 29(2): 557-562.
[10] Yin G, Gong D K, Liu B H, et al. Effects of Cistanche deserticola polysaccharide on learning and memory and oxidative stress in rats with Alzheimer's disease [J]. J Apoplexy Nerv Dis, 2013, 30(6): 504-507.
[11] Ma Y Q. A preliminary study on Cistanche plants in Inner Mongolia [J]. J Inn Mong Univ Nat Sci Ed, 1960(1): 61-69.
[12] Liu Y X. Flora of chinese desert plants: Volume II [M]. Beijing: Science Press, 1987.
[13] Liu G J. Cistanche deserticola and its artificial cultivation [M]. Beijing: China Labour and Social Security Press, 2003: 88.
[14] Tu P F, He Y P, Lou Z C. Survey and protection of medicinal resources of desert-living Cistanche (Cistanche deserticola) [J]. Chin Tradit Herb Drugs, 1994, 25(4): 205-208.
[15] National Pharmacopoeia Committee. Chinese pharmacopoeia: Volume I [M]. Beijing: China Medical Science Press, 2010: 126.
[16] National Pharmacopoeia Committee. Chinese pharmacopoeia: Volume I [M]. Beijing: China Medical Science Press, 2020: 141.
[17] National Pharmacopoeia Committee. Chinese pharmacopoeia: Volume I [M]. Beijing: China Medical Science Press, 2015: 135.
[18] National Pharmacopoeia Committee. Chinese pharmacopoeia: Volume I [M]. Beijing: China Medical Science Press, 2005: 90.
[19] National Pharmacopoeia Committee. Chinese pharmacopoeia: Volume I [M]. Beijing: The Commercial Press, 1963: 108.
[20] The standard list of medicinal materials in China has been published [J]. Chin Tradit Herb Drugs, 2011, 42(7): 1347.
[21] Sun X, Pei J, Zhao L, et al. Fighting climate change: Soil bacteria communities and topography play a role in plant colonization of desert areas [J]. Environ Microbiol, 2021, 23(11): 6876-6894.
[22] Sun X, Pei J, Lin Y L, et al. Revealing the impact of the environment on Cistanche salsa: From global ecological regionalization to soil microbial community characteristics [J]. J Agric Food Chem, 2020, 68(32): 8720-8731.
[23] Sun X, Zhang L, Pei J, et al. Regulatory relationship between quality variation and environment of Cistanche deserticola in three ecotypes based on soil microbiome analysis [J]. Sci Rep, 2020, 10(1): 6662.
[24] Sun X, Li L, Pei J, et al. Metabolome and transcriptome profiling reveals quality variation and underlying regulation of three ecotypes for Cistanche deserticola [J]. Plant Mol Biol, 2020, 102(3): 253-269.
[25] Wang Y, Zhang L, Du Z X, et al. Chemical diversity and prediction of potential cultivation areas of Cistanche herbs [J]. Sci Rep, 2019, 9(1): 19737.
[26] Huang L F, Zheng S H, Wu L B, et al. Ecotypes of Cistanche deserticola based on chemical component and molecular traits [J]. Sci Sin Vitae, 2014, 44(3): 318-328.
[27] Engler A. Das Pflanzenreich: regni vegetablilis conspectus [EB/OL]. [2025-12-16]. https://www.biodiversitylibrary.org/bibliography/250.
[28] Zhang Z Y. Taxonomy of the genus Cistanche (Orobanchaceae) in China [J]. J Pharm Pract, 2000, 18(5): 336-337.
[29] Chen M, Cui G H, Xiao S P, et al. Preliminary study on variation pattern of Cistanche deserticola [J]. China J Chin Mater Med, 2008, 33(19): 2179-2181.
[30] Zhang Z Y. Studies on the family Orobanchaceae of China (I) [J]. Bull Bot Res, 1984, 4(4): 111-119.
[31] National Pharmacopoeia Committee. Chinese pharmacopoeia: Volume I [M]. Beijing: China Medical Science Press, 2000: 103.
[32] National Pharmacopoeia Committee. Chinese pharmacopoeia: Volume I [M]. Beijing: China Medical Science Press, 1995: 111.
[33] National Pharmacopoeia Committee. Chinese pharmacopoeia: Volume I [M]. Beijing: China Medical Science Press, 1990: 110.
[34] National Pharmacopoeia Committee. Chinese pharmacopoeia: Volume I [M]. Beijing: China Medical Science Press, 1985: 106.
[35] National Pharmacopoeia Committee. Chinese pharmacopoeia: Volume I [M]. Beijing: The Commercial Press, 1977: 220.
[36] Tao H J. Supplementary records of famous physicians [M]. Beijing: People's Medical Publishing House, 1986: 88.
[37] Su J. The newly revised materia medica [M]. Shanghai: Shanghai Ancient Books Publishing House, 1985: 78-79.
[38] Rihuazi. Rihuazi materia medica [M]. Hefei: Anhui Science and Technology Publishing House, 2005: 123-125.
[39] Han B S. Restored and compiled edition of the Shu materia medica [M]. Beijing: Beijing Science and Technology Publishing House, 2021: 566-568.
[40] Liu H, Ma Z. Kaibao materia medica [M]. Hefei: Anhui Science and Technology Publishing House, 1998: 455-457.
[41] Cheng W G. Annotations to the Examination papers of the Song Imperial Medical Bureau [M]. Beijing: Xue Yuan Press, 2007: 588.
[42] Kou Z S. Extended meanings of materia medica [M]. Beijing: China Medical Science Press, 2019: 236.
[43] Su S. Illustrated classic of materia medica [M]. Fuzhou: Fujian Science and Technology Press, 1988: 127-128.
[44] Su S. Collated and edited edition of Illustrated classic of materia medica [M]. Beijing: Xue Yuan Press, 2017: 1658-1659.
[45] Hu S K. Supplemented and expanded rhymed formulas of materia medica based on the concise illustrated classic [M]. Beijing: Ancient Chinese Medical Texts Publishing House, 1963: 98.
[46] Cheng W. The complete medical guide [M]. Beijing: Ancient Chinese Medical Texts Publishing House, 1985: 126-127.
[47] Li G. Pearl bag's supplemental rhymed guide to drug properties [M]. Beijing: People's Military Medical Electronic Press, 2005: 85.






